‘What else do we have?’ Maine Democrats signal they’ll stick with Graham Platner, some with regret
‘What else do we have?’ Maine Democrats signal they’ll stick with Graham Platner, some with regret
What else do we have Maine – Despite recent scrutiny over his personal conduct, Graham Platner remains a strong contender for Maine’s Democratic Senate nomination. The upcoming primary on Tuesday has not shaken his chances, though some voters express mixed feelings about supporting him. A wave of negative reports about his behavior has left certain supporters questioning whether he has truly changed, even as they acknowledge the need for a candidate to challenge the Republican incumbent, Susan Collins.
Controversies Emerge
Platner, a Marine Corps veteran and oyster farmer, has been embroiled in a series of scandals that have cast doubt on his candidacy. Among the latest developments, a New York Times article published Thursday revealed accounts from three of his former girlfriends about their experiences in volatile, toxic relationships. These stories include allegations of excessive alcohol consumption, infidelity, disrespectful treatment of women, and one instance of physical aggression. While the article highlights these issues, Platner’s campaign has denied claims of physical intimidation, insisting he was unaware of the tattoo’s Nazi symbolism until it became a focal point of criticism.
“I don’t have a lot of faith he’s changed,” said Sandra Braden, a Portland resident. “But if he votes the way I want and can beat Susan Collins, I’ll still put a check next to his name.”
Braden’s sentiment reflects a growing divide among voters. While she admits discomfort with Platner’s past, she remains pragmatic about the election’s stakes. His ability to secure a Senate seat is seen as crucial for the party’s broader ambitions, particularly in the race to flip four GOP-held seats and gain a majority in the Senate. For Braden, the trade-off seems worth it: a candidate who may not embody the ideal Democratic values but could deliver results.
Supporters Hold Their Ground
Woody Hayward, another Maine voter, echoed a similar sentiment. He argued that the state needs “fresh blood” in the Senate, and while Platner’s controversies are troubling, they pale in comparison to the entrenched political establishment. “What else do we have, right?” Hayward asked, pointing to the current crop of candidates. “Zoo Cain isn’t really focused on his flaws, and he’s seen Platner speak. His vision is what matters.”
Cain, a prominent figure in the race, acknowledged Platner’s shortcomings but emphasized his potential. “He’s got some baggage, but way less than the oligarchy,” Cain said, referencing the perceived corruption of the current Senate leadership. This assessment aligns with Platner’s own confidence in his campaign, which he described as “fully committed till the end.” During an interview with MS NOW, he stated that ending his bid was never an option, even as personal scandals mounted.
Defenses and Context
Platner’s campaign has sought to frame his behavior within a broader narrative of personal struggle and growth. During a rally in Bar Harbor on Friday, he addressed critics head-on, vowing to stand by his supporters. “Every piece of my past is being dug up, litigated, and weaponized,” he said. “But you have my back. When people make false accusations, Maine has my back.”
Ro Khanna, a progressive representative from California, joined Platner in defending his candidacy. Speaking to hundreds at the event, Khanna noted that “most of us haven’t lived perfect lives.” He praised Platner for his willingness to take accountability, saying the candidate had shown remorse for his past actions. “He’s worked to be a better man,” Khanna added, linking Platner’s personal struggles to his military service. “Three combat tours in Iraq taught him resilience, and that’s part of who he is.”
“We broke thousands of young men by sending them into dumb wars and taking their factory jobs,” Khanna said. “That’s not an excuse, it’s the truth.”
While some argue Platner’s past behavior undermines his credibility, others see his resilience as a strength. His campaign has also taken steps to maintain momentum, scheduling a virtual town hall next Wednesday and holding an in-person event in Portland on Sunday. These efforts suggest a strategy to keep the conversation focused on his policy platform rather than his personal scandals.
A Race for the Senate Majority
The contest against Susan Collins, a five-term Republican senator, is more than just a local affair. For Democrats, securing a win in Maine could be a pivotal moment in their fight to reclaim the Senate. With national Democrats hesitant to intervene, Platner’s campaign has largely been self-sufficient. His wife, Amy, emphasized the family’s resolve, stating that “it has never crossed our mind to drop out of this thing.”
However, the race has not been without complications. Janet Mills, the state’s governor and a top Democratic pick, had suspended her campaign but remains on the ballot. This has sparked speculation about her potential return to the race, as a source close to her told CNN she is receiving encouragement to re-enter. “The Governor remains on the ballot,” the source noted, highlighting the uncertainty surrounding the primary’s outcome.
Remaining Challenges
Even as Platner and his allies push forward, the path to victory is fraught with obstacles. The tattoo controversy, which has been a recurring theme, continues to linger in voters’ minds. While Platner claimed ignorance about its origins, the image of a Nazi-linked symbol has been difficult to erase. Yet, for many, the issue is not the tattoo itself but the perception of a candidate who may not be fully transparent.
Khanna’s defense of Platner has also been notable, as he seeks to unify the party. “No one should make excuses for his past relationships,” Khanna said. “But we need to acknowledge that some were toxic and volatile. That’s part of the story, and it’s important to focus on his future.”
“He’s ashamed of some of the things he said and did, and he took accountability,” Khanna said. “That’s what matters now.”
As the primary approaches, the debate over Platner’s suitability for the Senate has intensified. While some voters express regret about their choice, others see him as the best available option. The outcome of Tuesday’s race will likely determine the direction of the Democratic Party in the months ahead, with stakes extending far beyond Maine’s borders.
For now, Platner’s campaign continues to emphasize his commitment to the cause. Whether that commitment will be enough to overcome the lingering doubts remains to be seen. But in a year where party unity is critical, his supporters argue that the alternative may be even less appealing. “What else do we have?” Hayward repeated, a question that may define the next chapter of the Democratic race in Maine.